Former premier Jason Kenney made the argument that Calgary and Edmonton would vote to remain in Canada and refuse to participate in secession.

 

X / jkenney (right)

Former premier Jason Kenney says that if Canada is divisible, Alberta is too. He predicts Calgary and Edmonton would vote to remain in Canada and refuse to participate in Alberta’s secession.

But a Calgary city council vote cannot detach Calgary from Alberta.

Kenney made the argument after Calgary council voted 14–1 to affirm the city’s place in Alberta and Canada. Council is free to take that position; however, it has no power to decide which country Calgary belongs to. Provincial law governs municipal boundaries, and Alberta makes the final decisions on proposed changes.

The legal process for a province is different. The federal Clarity Act addresses a province-wide referendum and a clear expression of will by the population of that province.

It does not give individual cities a separate vote to remain in Canada. A favourable provincial vote would not, by itself, make Alberta independent either: lawful secession would require negotiations and a constitutional amendment.

Kenney may predict how Calgarians and Edmontonians would vote. That prediction is not a legal mechanism for carving either city out of Alberta.