A significant portion of Albertans will be choosing Option 2 to send a message to the federal government.
Former Kim Campbell campaign adviser David McLaughlin posted on X: “Having failed to convince Albertans thus far to opt for separation, the leader of the secessionist pack is scrambling to gaslight voters on what Option 2 is. it is a vote for a separation referendum, period.”
Option 2 is not “a vote for a separation referendum, period,” and it is certainly not a vote for independence. That is the claim federalists keep flattening into a slogan. The ballot does not say that. The Order in Council does not say that. Elections Alberta does not say that.
Independence supporters are certainly supporting Option 2. But a large segment of Albertans are choosing Option 2 as a means of sending a message to Ottawa.
Stay Free Alberta petitioned to invoke a binary and binding referendum on Alberta independence, and it was shunted by the courts. The question facing Albertans on October 19 is mushy and, at its strongest, offers a non-binding mandate to the provincial government to commence the process to hold a binding independence referendum.
An Option 2 majority does not take Alberta out of Canada. It does not trigger the Secession Reference duty on Ottawa to negotiate the terms of departure. It does not schedule Independence Day. It tells Edmonton to begin the legal groundwork for a future binding question. If that future vote is ever held, Albertans would still have to choose to leave or stay. That is when a vote for independence would actually exist.
Calling that “gaslighting” is a campaign tactic, not a reading of the text. The gaslight runs the other way: treat a non-binding process question as if it were a declaration of independence, then dare anyone who wants leverage with Ottawa to prove they are still Canadian. Plenty of voters can want a stronger provincial hand without wanting a new country.
Voting to begin the process for a binding independence vote isn’t a minor decision. It could indeed lead to true and full independence for Alberta from the federation. Reframing the question being presented to Albertan citizens today as being one triggering secession is political posturing and disingenuous, however.
Signup
The legacy media is counting on one thing: that you'll see the false headline and never see the correction. Don't let them get away with it.
Sign up for email updates from Alberta Fact Check and we'll send every new fact check straight to you the moment it's published. You'll always know what was said, who said it, and exactly where they got it wrong. It's free, it takes ten seconds, and it's the easiest way to stay one step ahead of the spin.